The Bachelor: Oh, boy, there’s a new theory about Peter’s winner

A new Bachelor theory surfaces regarding the woman Peter ends up with.

The Bachelor theories are never-ending, and with just a few days left before the epic season finale, a new theory has emerged this week. During this week’s Women Tell All, Bachelor Nation fans noticed that Kelley Flanagan was MIA from the gathering. I mean, this isn’t the first time it’s happened, and it may have been overlooked if it wasn’t for the usual sleuthing fans of the franchise do.

With Kelley missing from the Women Tell All, we couldn’t help but wonder if it was because the production just didn’t want her there or if it was something else. If it was something else, then was that something else because that is who Peter Weber ends up with?

According to Kelley’s Instagram, she was in Los Angeles while the special was being filmed with all the other women. Was she actually at the taping but just not filmed or was she chilling backstage? Better yet, is she going to shock us all at the Final Rose ceremony?

It doesn’t make sense that Kelley wasn’t involved in the Women Tell All especially if she was in town and hanging out with the girls. So, one of the conclusions could be that is that she involved in this season’s Bachelor ending. Is that the big bombshell plot twist we didn’t see coming?!

But where this theory really catches on is the fact that Kelley follows all of Peter’s family on Instagram and they follow her. They don’t follow anyone else from the season, so what’s up with that? After all, Bachelor Nation fans figured out Colton and Cassie were together because of Venmo transactions, so this isn’t a far stretch.

But turning down this theory is none other than Bachelor Nation guru, Reality Steve, who says there is no validity to this theory.

There are some out there theorizing that not only is Kelley the woman that Peter ends up with, but she’s pregnant with his baby. This stems from the fact that the two met each other before filming began, and in the off-chance, they slept together, some think she is now pregnant.

Reality Steve is not about any of these theories and even states in his blog post that Kelley following Peter’s family and vice versa doesn’t mean a thing. I mean, the guy knows what he is talking about and hasn’t ever let us down so we’re inclined to take his word.

But what if, maybe, just maybe, there is some truth to this Kelley theory? It certainly fits all the crazy promos and would be completely unexpected, and throw Peter for a loop during his finale. Luckily, we don’t have to wait too long before finally learning what happens.

Monday can’t come fast enough!

Next: The Bachelor: Women Tell All addresses a very important issue

What do you think about this Bachelor theory? Share your thoughts below! 

Load Comments