
4. Dean Unglert
Now, this is definitely one of my sleeper picks on here. He has the potential to be pretty forgettable, actually; however, as a super fan, it’s pretty clear to me that he was for sure an unforgettable character during his time on the show.
He was a semi-repeater on Bachelor in Paradise. In season 5, he was caught in a pretty messy love triangle between him, Kristina Schulman, and Danielle Lombard. Coming back in season 6, he fell in love with Caelynn Miller-Keyes (there was still drama with her, but that’s a different story for a different day). Good thing Unglert met Miller-Keyes because to this day, they are still together…in the van! Caelynn originally didn’t like that idea, but they are happily ever after in their mobile home…together. Good for them! I really love those two together!

5. Carly Waddell
Carly is 1 million percent my number one sleeper pick. People might think of her name and realize that she didn’t really do much for them on the show.
Basically, here’s what she’s known and ultimately (most) remembered for. For one, she got heavily rejected and really badly blindsided by Kirk, who made history as one of the worst on-air breakups in Paradise history. Second off, she constantly rejected and turned down Evan Bass, whom she ultimately ended up with, got married to back in Mexico, and had two kids together. Unfortunately, they got divorced last year, but their relationship definitely had an interesting timeline, that’s for sure.