Why The Bachelor winner Cassie Randolph returned the ring Colton got

THE BACHELOR - "Season Finale, Night Two" - America watched live on Monday night as a devastated and extremely emotional Colton finally decided what would be best for him. He put everything on the line, but what will happen to him and the remaining women? Find out on night two of the two-night, live special Season Finale event on "The Bachelor," TUESDAY, MARCH 12 (8:00-10:00 p.m. EDT), on The ABC Television Network, streaming and on demand. (ABC/John Fleenor)COLTON UNDERWOOD, CASSIE
THE BACHELOR - "Season Finale, Night Two" - America watched live on Monday night as a devastated and extremely emotional Colton finally decided what would be best for him. He put everything on the line, but what will happen to him and the remaining women? Find out on night two of the two-night, live special Season Finale event on "The Bachelor," TUESDAY, MARCH 12 (8:00-10:00 p.m. EDT), on The ABC Television Network, streaming and on demand. (ABC/John Fleenor)COLTON UNDERWOOD, CASSIE /
facebooktwitterreddit

Neil Lane doesn’t usually disappoint, but The Bachelor winner Cassie Randolph doesn’t want the ring he made her. Here’s why she returned it.

By now, we all know the news: Cassie Randolph may have won her recent season of The Bachelor, but she is still not engaged to Colton Underwood. After a truly dramatic start to their relationship, this controversial pair agreed to continue dating one another without Colton actually putting a ring on it.

All that being said, there is actually still a ring in the mix. No, Colton didn’t get to take his Neil Lane pick straight from the set of the show. The Bachelor has strict rules about when you do or do not get to keep that shiny gem. He did, however, get gifted a Neil Lane piece courtesy of late night talk show host Jimmy Kimmel.

In this teaser for E!’s Lady Gang show, Colton reveals that he did get that ring ready for Cassie. . . but she didn’t like it. The double halo look he had ready for her was jokingly called a “Super Bowl ring” and the ladies of Lady Gang didn’t seem too surprised that Cassie wasn’t into it. Uh-oh. So what’s a Bachelor to do?

Colton, ever the dutiful boyfriend, opted to return the ring for Cassie. He actually called his girlfriend while he was filming the show and she commented simply, “”I just have a particular idea in my mind.”

Related Story. Cassie Randolph makes the move to Los Angeles to be closer to Colton. light

So what’s the etiquette here? Was it tacky for Cassie to return her ring from The Bachelor or was that totally justifiable as she didn’t have a hand in picking it? As many fans have been hesitant to support these two as a couple, the argument will almost certainly be made by someone that this is a sign of further turbulence to come in their relationship.

But what do you think, Bachelor Nation? Will Cassie change her mind and sport that “Super Bowl ring” still?